Outlook 1/31/00
By John Leo
The top 10 victims
The competition was stiff,
but these people made it to the big time
Many commentators have noticed that nobody is responsible
for anything anymore, since everybody is a victim. But with
all the lists of person of the year and man of the century,
where is the list of victims of the year? Right here. The top
10:
Jeremy Strohmeyer. Convicted of the rape-murder of a
7-year-old girl in the women's bathroom of a Las Vegas casino,
Strohmeyer went on 20/20 and portrayed himself as a
heartbreakingly unloved, abused, whacked-out, drugged-out
alcoholic who should not really be blamed for his crime. At
his trial he blamed the following: a therapist; a former
girlfriend; Los Angeles County adoption officials; his friend
David Cash, for not intervening to stop the murder when he
discovered the assault in progress; and Las Vegas casinos, for
allowing children to play at arcades.
Michael Costanza. A TV show has stolen his life,
according to his lawyer. This bald, stocky Long Island
real-estate agent says he is the model for the bald, stocky
George Costanza on the recently retired NBC sitcom
Seinfeld. Claiming that he was defamed by the character
and that his real-estate sales have suffered because the TV
Costanza is such a lout, the real-life Costanza is suing the
Seinfeld show for $100 million. "They've taken a lot
from him," said his lawyer. "They've taken his life."
Harold Crall. A Kentucky gynecologist, Crall
surrendered his medical license in 1994 after having what he
called "inappropriate contact with female patients." The
licensing board let him resume practicing medicine, but only
if he worked for the state corrections department and never
saw another female patient. Now Crall claims he is a victim of
sexual addiction and is suing his insurance company for $8,700
a month in disability benefits. The diagnosis of sexual
addiction isn't recognized by the American Psychiatric
Association. Many psychiatrists and psychologists consider it
imaginary. But Crall's psychiatrist says, "There is no
question in my mind, as with all addictions, a sexual
addiction is a disease with genetic predisposition." (Coming
next: disability claims from serial rapists.)
Aaron McKinney. Charged in the torture and beating
death of a Wyoming gay student, Matthew Shepard, McKinney said
the drug methamphetamine and "gay panic" syndrome made him do
it. McKinney said Shepard made sexual overtures, inducing an
almost unconscious fury for which he was not really
responsible. Prosecutor Cal Rerucha filed papers listing some
of McKinney's problems apparently not covered by a "gay panic"
defense: He had about 40 criminal and traffic citations in
Wyoming, some including criminal entry and making threats, and
once allegedly offered to have a woman's ex-husband
murdered.
Blaine Gamble and Deanna Emard. Gamble, charged with
bank robbery in Pennsylvania, told the court he was a victim
of cultural insanity, due to "unwarranted exposure,
victimization, and repetitive confrontation with white
racism." Emard, a Canadian Indian, after being convicted in
Vancouver of stabbing her common-law husband to death, told
the court she should not go to prison, in part because
"Indianness" made her do it. A 1996 Canadian penal law, citing
the high number of aboriginal people behind bars, allows light
sentences for offenders who have suffered from barriers
commonly faced by natives, such as alcoholism, drugs, physical
abuse, poverty, or attendance at a residential school for
Indians.
Michael Griffin. On trial for killing abortion
doctor David Gunn, Griffin blamed graphic photos of
dismembered fetuses. His lawyers said Griffin had been
"influenced" or "brainwashed" by antiabortion leader John
Burt.
James Moore. An upstate New York landscape gardener,
Moore raped and strangled a 14-year-old girl in 1962 and was
sentenced to life without parole. Last year he told a judge
that he should be freed because insecticides made him do it.
He argued that the chemicals brought on "episodes of mania . .
. the true cause of the depraved act on the young girl I
murdered."
Pizza Hut. Feeling victimized by the hurtful
pizza-box slogan of rival Papa John's ("Better ingredients,
better pizza"), Pizza Hut sued in federal court and won. A
jury in Dallas ruled that the Papa John's slogan was deceptive
and must be removed from boxes and ads.
Bill Clinton. In October, the Washington Post
reported that Clinton sees himself as a victim of media
bias. Citing "three people who have talked politics with him
recently," the Post reported that Clinton was galled by
George W. Bush's high standing in the polls, and is
"disdainful, too, of what he regards as the softball news
coverage of Bush, comparing it with the harsh scrutiny he
received, and attributing the difference to an elitist bias in
the media." This was the clearest positioning of Clinton as
victim since Arkansas writer Gene Lyons went on Meet the
Press to argue that the Lewinsky involvement might be seen
as "a totally innocent relationship in which the president,
was, in a sense, the victim of someone rather like the woman
who followed David Letterman around." In response, columnist
Michael Kelly wrote: "The poor man. The poor victim. My
God, how he must have suffered."